The 4-Minute Rule for Local News Online

How Local News Online can Save You Time, Stress, and Money.


It was down in the UK and Brazil but up a few other nations, such as Greece, Bulgaria, and Poland. This year, for the very first time, we inquired about the different methods that individuals stay clear of the news and located that around half of avoiders (53%) were trying to do so in a broad-brush or regular means for instance, by switching off the radio when the news began, or by scrolling past the information in social media sites.


You stated that you attempt to actively stay clear of information.


Base: Those that occasionally or often prevent the news in all markets = 33,469. In our qualitative research this year we've heard much more evidence regarding the scenarios that trigger this careful news evasion, also by those that are or else extremely interested. Particular newspaper article that are duplicated exceedingly or are felt to be 'em otionally draining' are often passed over in favour of something more uplifting.




The 45-Second Trick For Local News Online


I'm most likely choosing to learn more light-hearted stories than I utilized to currently. M, 51, UK Turning my back on information is the only means I feel I can deal often. I have to consciously make the initiative to turn away for the sake of my very own psychological health and wellness.




Local News OnlineLocal News Online
Careful avoidance of Ukraine information was greatest in a lot of the countries closest to the problem, strengthening searchings for from our added study in 2014, quickly after the battle had actually started. Our data might not recommend an absence of rate of interest in Ukraine from nearby nations yet rather a wish to take care of time or safeguard mental wellness from the extremely actual scaries of battle.


Contrasting Finland with a politically polarised country such as the USA (see following chart) that is much less affected by the battle, we locate a really different pattern of topic evasion. In the USA, we discover that customers are more most likely to stay clear of topics such as national politics and social justice, where discussions over issues such as sex, sexuality, and race have actually come to be extremely politicised.


American national politics are pretty hazardous nowadays. I discover occasionally that I need to separate from tales that simply make me angry. F, 61, USA For some people, bitter and divisive political arguments are a factor to switch off information completely, but also for some political upholders, evasion is frequently concerning shutting out point of views you do not desire to listen to.




3 Simple Techniques For Local News Online


Those on the left are extra most likely than those on the right to avoid news about criminal offense or company and finance. Proof that some people are averting from important information subjects, like the war in Ukraine, national politics, and also climate change is incredibly difficult for the news sector and for those who think the information media have a critical duty in educating the general public as component of a healthy and balanced democracy.




Local News OnlineLocal News Online
Some are seeking to make information extra available for hard-to-reach groups, widening the information agenda, commissioning more inspiring or positive news, or embracing positive or solutions journalism that give individuals a feeling of hope or personal agency. In our survey this year, we asked respondents concerning their rate of interest in these various strategies.


This discusses why stories like Ukraine or nationwide politics do well with news regulars but can at the same time transform much less interested individuals away. Discerning avoiders are less thinking about all kinds of news than non-avoiders yet in loved one terms they do appear to be much more interested in positive or solutions-based news.




Indicators on Local News Online You Should Know


Instead we can analyze this as an oft-stated wish for the information to be a little bit much less disappointing and a bit much easier to comprehend. M, 55, Germany There are no simple solutions to what is a diverse story of interference and low involvement navigate to this website in a high-choice electronic atmosphere, but our data recommend that less sensationalist, much less negative, and extra informative strategies might aid, particularly with those who have low interest in information.


2023). This might hold true in the moment, however in time it seems to be leaving many individuals empty and much less completely satisfied, which may be undermining our connection with and count on the news - Local News Online. Throughout markets, overall count on news (40%) and rely on the resources individuals utilize themselves (46%) are down by an additionally 2 portion factors this year


With the rear-view mirror, the COVID-19 depend on bump is clearly noticeable in the following chart, though the instructions of travel after that has actually been blended. In many cases (e.g. Finland), the trust fund boost has actually been maintained, while in others the upturn looks more like a blip in a tale of continued lasting decrease.


Some of the highest possible reported degrees of media objection are located in countries with highest possible levels of distrust, such as Greece, the Philippines, navigate to this website the USA, France, and the UK. The least expensive degrees of media criticism frequent those with higher degrees of trust, such as Finland, Norway, Denmark, and Japan.




Our Local News Online PDFs




This year we asked respondents regarding their preferences for message, sound and video when eating information online - Local News Online. Usually, we find that the majority still prefer to review the news (57%), instead of watch (30%) or pay attention to it (13%), yet younger individuals (under-35s) are most likely to listen (17%) than older groups


Behind the standards we locate substantial and shocking nation distinctions. In markets with a solid reading tradition, such as Finland and the UK, around 8 in ten still prefer to read on-line information, but in India and Thailand, around 4 in 10 (40%) say they prefer to see news online, and in the Philippines that percentage mores than half (52%).


In numerous Oriental nations, populaces have a tendency to be more youthful, mobile information often tend to be relatively inexpensive, and video information is extensively readily available by means of platforms such as YouTube and TikTok. In Thailand, for instance, greater opportunities for civil liberty online have caused the development of a spate of independent TV-style online reveals that are commonly taken in on mobile phones.




The Facts About Local News Online Uncovered


In the UK, a majority of 1824s still prefer message, yet they are much less most likely to wish to read on-line news compared to older teams, and have a additional resources stronger preference to watch as well as listen, recommending future online information behaviors may look really various in the following decade.


Around a 3rd of these (12%) gain access to an information podcast frequently, with the greatest development in the United States and Australia. Just under a 3rd (29%) state they have actually invested even more time listening to podcasts this year, with 19% saying they have listened much less. News makes up a fairly tiny proportion of podcasts in a lot of markets, but plays a larger duty in the USA (19%).

 

What Does Local News Online Do?

The Main Principles Of Local News Online


Most affordable degrees of worry are in less polarised European nations like the Netherlands, Germany, and Denmark. The biggest rise in issue came in Hong Kong this year (+6) as the conflict in between the government and pupil protesters continued and also in Finland (+4 ), where we see more than average problem over false and deceptive information from international governments.




Local News OnlineLocal News Online
Please suggest your level of agreement with the adhering to declaration. Believing regarding on-line news, I am worried concerning what is genuine and what is fake on the net. Base: Total example in each market 2000, Taiwan = 1027. Residential politicians are viewed as a lot of liable (40%) for false and deceptive details online, complied with by political protestors (14%), journalists (13%), average people (13%), and international governments (10%).


In the most polarised countries, this effectively implies selecting your side. Local News Online. Left-leaning opponents of Donald Trump and Boris Johnson are much more likely responsible these political leaders for spreading lies and half-truths online, while their right-leaning fans are most likely to blame reporters. In the United States more than 4 in 10 (43%) of those on the appropriate blame reporters for misinformation echoing the Head of state's anti-media unsupported claims contrasted with simply 35% of this team stating they are most concerned regarding the behavior of politicians




All About Local News Online


Which of the adhering to, if any kind of, are you most worried concerning online? Incorrect or deceptive information fromBase: Total sample = 80155 Damaging the social information down additionally, across all nations 29% state they are most concerned regarding Facebook, complied with by YouTube (6%) and Twitter (5%). In parts of the International South, such as Brazil, people claim they are much more worried regarding shut messaging apps like WhatsApp (35%).


This is a certain concern because false information often tends to be less noticeable and can be more challenging to counter in these personal and encrypted networks. By contrast, in the Philippines (47%) and the USA (35%) the frustrating worry is about Facebook, with other networks playing a bit part. Twitter is attended be the most significant trouble in Japan and YouTube in South Korea.




Local News OnlineLocal News Online
All markets FAKE_NEWS_2020c. Which of the complying with, if any, are you most concerned concerning online? Please select one. False or misleading details fromBase: Total example in each market 2000, Taiwan = 1027. The coronavirus situation has reminded us that these networks can be utilized to spread all kinds of damaging misinformation, not almost national politics.


This is regular with our earlier information which suggest most of people wish to compose their own mind as opposed to be told what to believe by a journalist or to really feel that details was being held back. For even more evaluation see: Just how do People Want the Media to Cover Politics? It is too early to predict the full effect of the COVID-19 situation on the information sector yet it is nearly particular to be a stimulant for more cost-cutting, debt consolidation, and also much faster adjustments in organization versions.




The Of Local News Online


Local News OnlineLocal News Online
Have you paid for ONLINE news content, or accessed a paid for ONLINE information solution in the last year? Have you paid for ONLINE news web content, or accessed a paid-for ONLINE news solution in the last year?


Looking back, we can spot 2 clear waves of membership growth in the USA. The first was triggered by the election of Donald Trump, with several younger and liberal citizens a fantastic read seeking to support magazines that could hold the Head of state to account. This year's uptick might be partially driven by a new political election cycle but additionally by publisher methods to limit the amount of material people can see absolutely free integrated with special bargains.


Several fear expanding degrees of info inequality, where individuals with less money come to be more depending on social media and various other low-grade information while those who can afford it improve details. Currently levels of problem concerning this issue from respondents are highest in the USA (24%) and Norway (17%).


This year we conducted a second more thorough study in 3 countries (United States, UK, and Norway) to understand even more concerning patterns and perspectives to online news settlement. This research plainly reveals that a couple of large national information brand names have been the largest winners in all 3 countries. Around half of those that register for any type of online or combined package in the USA use the New York Times or the Washington Post and a similar proportion subscribe to either The Times or the Telegraph in the UK, though in much smaller numbers.




Local News Online Fundamentals Explained




One surprise in these data is the level to which people subscribe to local and local papers online in Norway (64%) - Local News Online. A lot of local information authors in Norway charge for on-line news, with a total amount of 129 different local titles stated by our participants. In the United States 30% register for several neighborhood titles, with 131 various titles stated


UK, United States, Norway PAY3. You claimed that you presently have access to a single information brand name. Please list every one of the on-line brands you 'd generally have to spend for that you currently have accessibility to. Base: All who have accessibility to a single information brand: United States = 584, UK = 269, Norway = 751.


The cost-free trials appear to be twice as common in the USA (10%), where competition for a minimal pool of clients is extremely strong. For more arise from our detailed pay survey check my reference see: Just how and Why Individuals are Spending For Online Information Donations for information are fairly new, though Wikipedia and National Public Radio have actually produced a lot of their revenue in this manner for years.


In the United States 4% now say they give away cash to an information organisation, 3% in Norway, find out here and 1% in the UK. The Guardian has among one of the most effective contribution versions of any kind of significant brand name, with over a million individuals having actually added in the last year. According to our information, practically half of all the fairly handful of contributions in the UK (42%) most likely to the Guardian, however a lot of are one-off, with an average settlement of less than 15.




Some Of Local News Online


Sector assumptions need to be practical as numerous individuals are most likely to have less disposable revenue and the majority of non-payers are still broadly happy with cost-free resources. The COVID-19 interruption is likely to strike local information service providers hardest, given their proceeding dependence on both print and electronic advertising and marketing. Industrial local papers in particular are a key part of democracy in numerous countries, employing most of journalists, highlighting local problems, and holding political leaders to account.

 

The Ultimate Guide To News Websites

Facts About News Websites Uncovered


They are: Being able to listen to, determine, and play with specific noises in spoken words. Being able to connect the letters of composed language with the sounds of talked language.


Being able to understand and get indicating from what has actually read. Being able to check out text precisely and swiftly. While children will certainly come across these proficiency abilities and language advancement once they get to grade school and past, you can assist boost their reading success by reading to them throughout early stage and their very early kid years.


It goes without stating that reading to your young child regularly can help you forge a more powerful relationship with them. When it pertains to youngsters, one of one of the most vital things you can do to favorably affect their development is hang out with them. Reviewing to your children provides a fantastic possibility to establish up a normal, common event where you can anticipate costs time together.




Getting The News Websites To Work


The value of trust fund to children can not be overstated. Checking out a favored book to your kids not only helps you bond with them, yet also offers your youngsters a feeling of intimacy and wellness. This sensation of intimacy assists your youngster really feel close to you, and the feelings of love and attention urge favorable growth and advancement.


Extremely young children love to hear acquainted voices, and analysis is the best outlet to produce this connection. At a more comprehensive, more clinical level, it's the parent-child connection, nurturing connections in between caretakers and youngsters that establish a positive life training course. If you have the ability to check out aloud with your youngster at a predictable, scheduled time that fits with the day-to-day routines of home and institution, you'll have the ability to offer something constant that they can expect and most likely also look onward to.


And in the future, reading with each other can be used to talk about real-life experiences and problems. A youngsters's book can give springboards to meaningful conversations regarding several subjects which can additionally create a youngster's vital reasoning skills. At its core, literary works is one of the most effective means to help youngsters understand something without always having to experience it on their own.




Reviewing aloud presents books as sources of pleasant, valuable, and exciting experiences. Kids who value books are motivated to read on their very own, and will likely remain to exercise independent analysis throughout the rest of their lives. When it pertains to reading to your kids, the advantages to your youngster's life variety far past the growth of a close bond with them, although that's absolutely among them.




How News Websites can Save You Time, Stress, and Money.


To get more information concerning our resources for youngsters, browse through.


According to Bench Proving Ground, 75% of grownups in the United States claimed they read a publication in the last year. Americans are reviewing less publications now than they did in the previous according to an U.S. Gallup Poll. While the survey really did not recognize why Americans read fewer publications, we can all take an informed guess from loaded household, job and day-to-day life duties to numerous various other options for amusement, you might not have the time or wish to read a book.


Some of you may not think about publications a kind of enjoyment, but they certainly can be. Books can make us laugh and cry and develop intrigue and excitement. Being captivated also has positive health and wellness advantages consisting of launching endorphins in your brain. These feel-good hormones help you kick back, manage pain and soothe stress.




News WebsitesNews Websites
Empathy is a vital personality quality people can develop. It assists us connect to other individuals and motivates us to be kind and considerate of other individuals's feelings. As it transforms out, analysis can really assist boost empathy. When people check out tales concerning other individuals's lives, it aids them develop the skills to comprehend the world through another person's viewpoint.




How News Websites can Save You Time, Stress, and Money.


One means analysis does this is via enhancing something called "concept of the mind." Theory of mind is the capacity to associate psychological states like beliefs, intents, wishes or emotions to others and to recognize that various other individuals have various beliefs, intents and desires than our own. When you read literary fiction, you're deepening your understanding of other read this post here individuals's ideas, feelings and desires.


Publications, on the various other hand, can aid you rest much better. Checking out helps you unwind and can indicate your body that it's time to go to rest.




News WebsitesNews Websites
The words make sense within the context of what you're reviewing so it makes it simpler to keep in mind later on. here It may seem unlikely, but analysis can in fact make you really feel happier.


Historically, analysis has been utilized to help people with challenging times. The belief was that the books could assist troops recover from the trauma of battle.




4 Simple Techniques For News Websites


It helps us relate to various other individuals and urges us to be kind and considerate of various other individuals's feelings. When people check out stories regarding various other people's lives, it aids them develop the skills to recognize the world with another person's point of view.


One way analysis does this is through improving something called "theory of the mind." Theory of mind is the ability to attribute psychological states like ideas, intents, wishes or emotions to others and to recognize that various other people have different beliefs, intents and desires than our very own. When you review literary fiction, you're strengthening your understanding of other individuals's ideas, emotions and needs.


Books, on the other hand, can aid you rest better. Checking out helps you unwind and can signal your body that it's time to go to sleep.


It's a lot easier to discover vocabulary from a publication than from remembering words in the dictionary. That's due to the fact that you're finding out the words contextually. Words make sense within the context of what you read so it makes it easier to bear in mind later. It go to my site may appear unlikely, however reading can in fact make you feel happier.




Our News Websites Ideas


It can assist us battle feelings of isolation or loneliness. Historically, analysis has actually been used to assist individuals via difficult times (News Websites). During WWI, the USA' Library War Service, an initiative that started with the Collection of Congress, collected over 700 million reading materials for soldiers. The idea was that the publications can aid troops heal from the injury of battle.

 

The Best Guide To Breaking News

Some Of Breaking News


Connecting your story to an associated tale that is happening today is called "piggybacking". Holidays and other unique dates that offer a great backdrop to your point of view - Breaking News. A tale about the job you have actually done to minimize driving while intoxicated can appear on New Year's Eve, a night when many individuals are driving vehicles after drinking a great deal of alcoholic beverages


In the event that you don't have a damaging story to toss on the media's plate, you have to make your very own news. Use your imagination to offer boring facts or numbers and old information a renovation.


You ought to also check out the papers that you would love to be in. Notice the by-lines of the press reporters who are composing articles of passion and target them for outreach. Bear in mind that press reporters remain in the company of discovering news. They will certainly value great tale ideas, also if they can not follow up that day or week.


If you have no idea who to speak to first, check out your pitch on the information or basic job editors. The newspaper has several areas: an information press reporter might not be interested in a soccer champion story, but the sporting activities reporter will certainly be. A couple of tips can make the call easier:.




The Ultimate Guide To Breaking News


The reporter will be taking cues from you. Give them plenty of time to do the ideal feasible work on your tale. Be a fast, dependable, and reliable source for news.


respect their due dates and help them satisfy them. This may suggest going down whatever and not ending up an additional job you intended for the day, however it is worth it. You are constructing relationships and a track record that will motivate press reporters to call you to find out what's taking place and aid get their interest when you intend to present.


Stories might or may not appear of these get in touches with, however they will certainly keep the media educated concerning you and your job, and will make them all the much more prepared to deal with tales when they show up. Media advocacy is not a single effort: it's a long-term endeavor, and it should take place as long as your organization needs support forever.




The smart Trick of Breaking News That Nobody is Discussing


Louis Chess Club St. Louis Chess Club The High court rescinded the constitutional right to abortion on June 24, 2022. Tracy Lee for NPR Tracy Lee for NPR Boeing introduced a major managerial shakeup consisting of that chief executive officer Dave Calhoun will certainly tip down at the end of the year. The embattled planemaker likewise said the president of the commercial airplanes division would certainly retire and its board chairman would certainly not stand for reelection.




Friday early morning to listen to Kevin Bacon's news on The TODAY Show. Jenny Staheli Jenny Staheli A Chick-fil-A location in Philly is revealed Wednesday, Nov. 17, 2021.


on Wedensday, March 20th, 2024. Stumpy along with 150 more trees will be cut down later this spring as part of a job to restore and increase the seawalls around the container. Zayrha Rodriguez/NPR Zayrha Rodriguez/NPR A group collects in front of Temple Aaron in Trinidad, Colorado on March 23, 2024.


Those designs show that one more 228 areas are at high danger of look these up losing neighborhood information. In producing that "View Listing," Medill researchers and data researchers used the qualities of current news deserts to regions with only one news resource - Breaking News.


The majority of the digital-only start-ups are based in metro areas, exacerbating the divide in America in between news-haves and have-nots. Likewise brand-new this year, the State of Local News Job, in partnership with Microsoft, produced a "Intense Areas" map revealing all local information startups in the U.S. as they have actually shown up over the past five years.




Breaking NewsBreaking News
The loss of local papers visit this website ticked greater in 2023 to a standard of 2.5 per week, up from 2 per week last year. The country is on speed to lose one-third of all its newspapers by the end of following year.


Based upon the demographics and business economics of current information desert regions, Medill's modeling estimates that 228 regions go to an elevated danger of coming to be information deserts in the following five years. Many of those "View List" areas are located in high-poverty areas in the South and Midwest, and numerous offer neighborhoods with substantial African American, Hispanic and Indigenous American populaces.




The 7-Second Trick For Breaking News


That gives leaders in those regions, benefactors, capitalists and policymakers a possibility to act prior to a news desert is developed. "In addition to recording the present state of play, we wished to make the report extra onward looking and diagnostic this year," claimed Franklin, who likewise functions as Medill's elderly associate dean.




Breaking NewsBreaking News
The foundation of both our goal and company is giving the most reliable protection of one of the most vital and interesting tales (Breaking News). This coverage is basic rate of interest, indicating it's crafted for a broad audience. It is additionally multimedia, thoughtfully using every go to this site major storytelling style posts, newsletters, digital photography, interactive graphics, information visualization, sound, video clip and occasions to best offer our audience

 

The 10-Minute Rule for Usa Online News

Facts About Usa Online News Uncovered


The authors of Stanton claimed, "Maintain throwing it on our yard (USA Online News). We rejoice to have it!"


That's what you review, isn't it?' Especially, we find that: Importance is the extremely important vehicle driver of news intake. Individuals find those tales most appropriate that impact their personal lives, as they impinge on participants of their family members, the location where they work, their pastime, and their neighborhood community. Relevance is tied to sociability.


Individuals frequently click on stories that are amusing, insignificant, or strange, with no evident civic focus. On the entire individuals desire to stay informed regarding what goes on around them, at the regional, national, and global degrees.




Usa Online News Fundamentals Explained


On top of that, we identified 4 details kinds of information rate of interest 4 teams of people with typical repertoires of newspaper article they take a passion in. Each of these four collections is composed of a diverse diet regimen of news stories that come from several subject areas, crossing common categories such as 'tough' and 'soft' information, or politics and amusement.


To the degree that reporters prioritise newspaper article with civic worth, they should trust their reactions as opposed to relying on the undependable seismograph offered by 'The majority of Read' listings. In spite of well-publicised hazards to the news sector, participants of the general public have never had much more information to select from than they do today.


We use element analysis coupled with comprehensive meetings to recognize individuals's information choices in the terms they themselves use, exploring their sense of news importance and the degree of public passion it mirrors. Our approach allows hidden patterns in individuals's news story preferences to emerge, without enforcing the groups that researchers and reporters typically take for given.




USA Online NewsUSA Online News
Checklists of 'The Majority Of Read' or 'Most Shared' tales, for example, are based upon exposed news choices as determined by click-through rates, time spent, or various other forms of audience engagement with private tales. Researchers have raised problems regarding the picture disclosed by such data (e.g. Boczkowski and Mitchelstein 2013). Subjects like entertainment, celebrity, rumor, and 'strange information' dominate 'Most Check out' lists, recommending viewers de-prioritise the general public affairs stories valued by journalists in favour of trivial stories with less autonomous value.




10 Simple Techniques For Usa Online News


For the viewers, they will often be new to them. An additional factor 'A lot of Review' rankings may diverge from people's larger information rate of interests can be discovered in why not find out more the press factors associated to mathematical option, which trigger even more people to be exposed to stories that are already trending upwards in terms of sort or shares.


It is important not to assume that all stories in the star and 'unusual' categories are democratically worthless. On the other hand, current study recommends that apparently trivial news stories are often reviewed in manner ins which go across over into autonomous concerns (Eide and Knight 1999) and may become a stimulant for public involvement (Papacharissi 2010).


We agree with Cherubini and Nielsen that 'all types of analytics have to confront the constraints associated with making use of measurable indications to comprehend the untidy and diverse realities of how individuals involve with journalism, why, and what it implies' (2016: 34) - USA Online News. As the next area lays out, this study is made to locate alternate approaches for comprehending people's passion in public events information


Stories were additionally chosen for potential long-lasting rate of interest; breaking news can not be included, because the research was executed over numerous weeks. This report draws mostly on outcomes of the card sorting in stage 3. For this workout, each story was stood for on a basic card showing a headline and a quick subheading, printed in a neutral typeface (see Box 1 and Appendix A).




Getting The Usa Online News To Work


Individuals were handed the 36 information story cards and asked to arrange them into three heaps: stories they would most likely wish to read if they encountered them on-line, in print, or on social networks; tales they most likely would not intend to you can check here read; and in between a stack with tales they might wish to review, time and place permitting.




They were additionally informed they could alter the setting of any kind of card till the total setup revealed their information tale choices. When completed, the grid therefore showed participants' position of each tale about link the other 35 newspaper article. Figure 2 One participant's ranking of the 36 news story cards between 'Likely to check out' and 'Not most likely to review' By mathematically connecting the tale positions of the 24 individuals utilizing aspect evaluation, we have the ability to recognize 4 distinctive collections of study participants whose news preferences were most comparable.




USA Online NewsUSA Online News
For many, 'information' appears to include both difficult news ('the information') and softer ranges ('newsy points'). The ultimate moderator of whether they wind up engaging with tales is regarded importance, irrespective of where the story drops on that continuum - USA Online News. People sometimes find it tough to find up with explicit reasons why they would certainly, or would certainly not, review a tale: what makes it appropriate or not is selected an user-friendly basis


That's what you read, isn't it? That's why you notify yourself due to the fact that you wish to know what's taking place and just how it's mosting likely to effect on you and your life and your work. That's what is very important. Because you are pestered with information everywhere yet you only soak up right stuff that's actually that you that is appropriate to you, unless you're resting there all the time watching TV.




Usa Online News for Dummies


(Elizabeth P15) Overall nonetheless, individuals explain their relevance top priorities quite lucidly as they sort the 36 newspaper article cards, and show an eager recognition of the commercial incentives that result in the diverse news fare they discover everyday. As one clarifies, So the most likely, for me, would be either things that are going to influence on me directly, or points that I have an energetic rate of interest in.

 

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15